Category Archives: Question Period

Recaps from Question Period in the House of Commons

Commence the 42nd parliament

Posted on by

There was general excitement, and MPs milled about, getting to know one another or to see colleagues they had not seen in some time. When the appointed hour arrived, there was a call to order, and the knock at the door from the Usher of the Black Rod, summoning MPs to the Senate. There, the Governor General’s deputy, Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin, awaited. MPs filtered out of the Chamber, headed down to the Other Place, where they were told that they wouldn’t be admitted until they had a Speaker. So back to the Commons they went.

Continue reading →

Senate QP: A perfectly legitimate mechanism

Posted on by

For what was possibly the final day of the Senate’s sitting, there was some tension after the shenanigans on Friday. Things got off with a single statement, regarding the terror attacks last week, and then it was onto Routine Proceedings. The deputy government leader, Yonah Martin, tabled a motion that the next sitting of the Senate would see them rise until mid-September. “You’ll be pretty lonely,” a Liberal senator heckled, knowing an election would be taking place then.

Continue reading →

Senate QP: Intelligence sharing questions

Posted on by

It was an early start in the Senate, and only one statement was made, regarding the committee report on on-reserve First Nations housing. Routine proceedings sped along, and the QP started, Senator Mitchell asked about the recent media reports on intelligence information sharing, and that the agencies asked only for more sharing and not broad powers. Carignan talked about protecting Canadians from jihadis and then raised the news of today’s attacks in France and Tunisia. Senator Plett tried to rise on a supplemental, but Mitchell wasn’t finished yet, and after some back-and-forth, Mitchell carried on with the questions about the unnecessary overreach in C-51 that CSIS didn’t ask for, but Carignan insisted they were concerned about the safety of Canadians. Mitchell noted the lack of oversight for intelligence agencies and how that would show leadership, but Carignan moved immediately to partisan swipes, saying he felt safer with Harper than with Trudeau. Mitchell started mocking Harper’s “leadership” in not getting pipelines, and asked again about oversight, and Carignan insisted things were great with SIRC. Mitchell gave one last attempt to get more of a commitment to oversight, but it did not happen.

Continue reading →

Senate QP: Sole-sourcing shipyard contracts

Posted on by

With all government business taken care of, a showdown was brewing in the Senate over Bill C-377, a “union busting” bill the government wants passed, but Liberals and a few Conservatives are doing their best to filibuster it into the ground. Things got started with the usual statements by senators (Canada Day in Quebec, the situation in Burundi, the good work of the Senate, the Terry Fox Run), and Routine Proceedings.

Continue reading →

Senate QP: What about the Rule of Law?

Posted on by

As the final days of the 41st Parliament continue to grind toward its end, the Senate was back in action for what was possibly the last day. After Senators’ statements (Commemoration of the Air India bombing, the Armendian genocide, Ramadan) and Routine Proceedings, and when Question Period started, Senator Moore led off, asking about the Federal Court order to turn the gun registry data hard drive over, and wondered why the government wound itself on the wrong side of the law. Answering for the government, Senator Carignan praised the end of the registry. Moore was not impressed, and wondered why Canadians should follow the law if the government wouldn’t. Carignan repeate his answer. Moore pressed, noting that the government has not followed the will of parliament in the past — noting the contempt charge at the close of the previous parliament — but Carignan stuck to his talking points. Moore raised Magna Carta, and wondered why the government felt itself above the Rule of Law. Carignan reiterated that the destruction was the will of Parliament. Moore raised the contempt motion and wondered if the government gets to pick and choose which laws it gets to follow. Carignan noted the election. Moore did not let up, at which point Carignan raised the spectre of Justin Trudeau and how he would undo everything, saying he was not ready to be Prime Minister. Moore wondered why it as acceptable that Harper could consider himself as the person who makes the rules, but Carignan retreated to his talking points.

Continue reading →

Senate QP: Dodging with accusations of partisanship

Posted on by

It’s not often that the full Senate sits on a Monday — usually it’s just committees that meet — but here they were, looking to get through the number of bills that the Commons sent down before they rose for the summer. Once senators’ statements (Magna Carta, praise for Senate Protective Services, World Refugee Day) and Routine Proceedings were though, it began. Senator Munson led off, bringing forward a question from a Canadian from Barrie, who asked about the rising costs of tuition — acknowledging the provincial role but also the role the federal government plays in things like student loans and grants. Senator Carignan, answering for the government, listed off the measures that the government has adopted, including tax measures, loans and grants, and the other supports they have given to students in the current budget. Munson thanked him for the answer, but wanted some more answers on the rising tuition and compulsory fees. Carignan noted the provincial jurisdiction, and the increased health and social transfers to the provinces. Senator Moore rose on a supplemental, asking if it was possible to get a breakdown for the social transfers to know how much was going to education. Carignan directed him to the website, but Moore, disputed that the information was available. Carignan this time implored them to support the budget. Moore rose again, asking about forgiving student loan interest, or free tuition for students like they do in some countries like Ireland. Carignan noted it was a significant sum of money available in the budget after referring the substance of Moore’s question to the provinces.

Continue reading →

Senate QP: Climate change as national security

Posted on by

The Senate was sitting early on a Friday, something they tend to do toward the end of any sitting in order to start passing the glut of legislation the Commons rushed through toward the end. Before things got off, there were a couple of brief tributes to the pending retirement of Senator Marjory LeBreton, as she turns 75 on July 4th.

When Question Period started, Senator Grant Mitchell rose to raise the Prime Minister’s lack of alacrity with it considering that it has real security and defence implications, which Harper likes to tout his respect for. Answering for the government, Government Leader in the Senate, Claude Carignan, gave a bland talking point about the action being taken. Mitchell rose for a supplemental, noting that if the right wing in the U.S. is getting the urgency of the issue, why couldn’t the PM get the urgency either? Carignan said that it was not their intention to get involved in the domestic policy south of the border, and touted the “fair and ambitious” target for 2100. Mitchell rose again, BC’s strong economy with its carbon tax. Carignan noted that the government has reduced greenhouse gasses.

And that was it. Short and sweet.

Sartorially speaking, snaps go out to Senator Dennis Dawson for a navy jacket with a light blue shirt and a red bow tie, and to Senator Lillian Eva Dyck for a white jacket with a white top and off-white trousers. Style citations go out to Senator Rose-May Poirier for a fluorescent pink and grey leopard print overshirt with a black top and trousers, and to Senator Tobias Enverga for a dark brown suit with a dull light blue shirt and a black and blue striped tie.

QP: One last scattershot attempt

Posted on by

It was likely the final Commons Question Period of the 41st Parliament (but it looks like not), and not a moment too soon. Not unsurprisingly, most of the leaders have already fled for the pre-writ campaign trail, with the exception of Elizabeth May, who dutifully remains at her desk until the bitter end. Megan Leslie led off, raising the moral issue of climate change per the Pope’s encyclical, but turned it into an NDP pitch instead of a question. Leona Agulkkaq chose a climate change talking point and recited it dutifully. Leslie then moved to the issue of sexual harassment in the military, to which James Bezan rose to denounce the comments made by the Chief of Defence Staff and to note that the wheels were already in motion for a change of command. Leslie asked for an inquiry into missing and murdered Aboriginal women, to which Kellie Leitch insisted that they were taking action. Niki Ashton picked up, denounced the government and raised a report on the wage gap between First Nations and other Canadians. Bernard Valcourt noted the measures the government has taken to improve the lives of First Nations. Ashton then raised a plethora of social issues faced by First Nations children and asked a rhetorical question about the government discriminating against them. Valcourt insisted that they were taking action to improve their lives. Ralph Goodale led for Liberals, decrying the government’s economic performance to which Kevin Sorenson read some talking points about lowering taxes and the Liberals raising them. Goodale dug in, but Sorenson repeated his usual talking points about how great ever high was. Dominc LeBlanc took the final slot to further the condemnation in the other official language, to which Candice Bergen stood up to defend the government’s record of keeping promises.

Continue reading →

QP: Like a greatest hits package 

Posted on by

All of the leaders were present today, for probably the last time in the 41st parliament. And hey, government computer systems were under a cyberattack as it went off, so that was exciting. Thomas Mulcair led off, asking about General Lawson’s comments on “biological wiring” as it relates to sexual harassment in the military and what the government would do about it. Harper denounced the comments and noted that Lawson apologised immediately and that they would implement the recommendations of Justice Deschamps. Mulcair asked again in English, demanding a personal commitment by the PM to changing the culture of the military, but Harper repeated his response but cautioned Mulcair against slurs against all members of the military. Mulcair then changed topics to the RCMP deletion of those gun registry records and wondered about the PMO role in encouraging them to do so. Harper insisted that they acted under the law. Mulcair then brought up the Senate audit, and wondered about the residency of Senator Carolyn Stewart Olsen (who was not named in said audit). Harper, a bit testy, brought up the NDP satellite offices. Mulcair turned to another senator’s mileage claims, to which Harper said that they were inventing things and reminded them of the satellite offices again. Justin Trudeau was up next, returning to the issue of sexual harassment in the military, and wondered why the PM would not immediately dismiss the Chief of Defence Staff for comments that he himself condemned. Harper returned to his previous response, following a dig at Trudeau. A second round in French got the same response again, and for his final question, Trudeau touted his plans for a revised Supreme Court appointment process, and rhetorically asked why the PM doesn’t commit to appointing bilingual judges. Harper insisted that the institution was already bilingual, and not every member was required to be.

https://twitter.com/davidakin/status/611239298713698305

Continue reading →

QP: Counselling illegal behaviour

Posted on by

It being a Tuesday, Stephen Harper was present for QP, a rarity these days — it’s too bad that neither Jusin Trudeau was (despite being in town but apparently had a thing with his children), nor Thomas Mulcair (who was giving a speech in Toronto). Megan Leslie led off, bemoaning the economic situation the country finds itself in. Stephen Harper disputed her, praising the post-recession job creation record. Leslie noted the drop in manufacturing numbers, using it to plug Mulcair’s speech, but Harper repeated his previous points. Leslie tried again, but Harper insisted that the NDP were only at the mercy of big union bosses, and that brought economic ruin in Europe. Peter Julian then picked up, and wondered why the government was allergic to democracy and the facts. Stephen Blaney responded, saying that the “group in question” supports a terrorist organization, and a second round in English went exactly the same. Ralph Goodale led for the Liberals, condemning the government for “counselling illegal behaviour” when it came to the destruction of those gun registry records. Harper insisted that the RCMP acted on the will of parliament, and that the Liberals simply wanted to revive it. Goodale ripped into him for the response, but Harper more forcefully repeated that it was the will of parliament, and that the Liberals hated farmers and duck hunters. Stéphane Dion took another kick at it in French, going after the retroactive legislation burried in the omnibudget bill to protect the RCMP, but Harper would not change in his talking points.

https://twitter.com/aaronwherry/status/610876361096495104

Continue reading →