There was an analysis piece over on the CBC site over the weekend about the prime minister’s budget promise around ending homelessness, and whether that’s something the federal government can do, with the parenthetical (not alone). Right. So where was the discussion around the culpability of the provinces and premiers in this discussion. Aside from mention that prime minister Mark Carney launched this initiative with the cooperation of Manitoba premier Wab Kinew, there was a couple of mentions of “conversations” with provinces, but nothing substantive about how provinces have fallen down on this kind of thing in the past.
There was a section in the piece about Justin Trudeau’s pledge to cut “chronic” homelessness in half, and how that failed (it’s now higher than when Trudeau took office) in part because they essentially didn’t spend enough to supportive housing, meaning deeply subsidised housing with social supports. The problem with this theory, however, is that these are areas of provincial jurisdiction and responsibility. Yes, Trudeau got the federal government back into the social housing game after it had existed in the early nineties, both as a result of the Chrétien government’s cuts and downloading of costs, but if you also listen to ministers from that era such as Sheila Copps, they will tell you that the provinces also wanted the federal government out of the housing sector because it was their responsibility and they could “spend the money better.” Of course, they didn’t, and even when the social transfers increased again a few years later, it didn’t find its way back into housing. Trudeau set about reversing that just as a series of overlapping crises rocked the country, meaning that the scale and scope of the problem got a lot bigger.
I will keep banging this drum, but we’re going to find that nothing will change until we hold provinces accountable for their failures in areas of their responsibility, most especially housing and healthcare because they are always quick to blame the federal government in those areas. (It’s harder for them to blame when it comes to education because there is no federal component, but the scapegoating around immigration is one such attempt). And Carney making this province with only a single premier on board is likely to find himself wearing the failure a few years down the road as things get worse in the current economic climate, while premiers continue to do the bare minimum and then complain that the federal government didn’t build enough housing or provide enough money for adequate supports when they have their own revenue tools for areas in their own jurisdiction. Until Carney is willing to stare down the premiers in the media, nothing is going to change, and he’ll wear their failures, no matter how high his polling numbers happen to be at the moment.
My Latest:
My weekend column calls out Gary Anandasangaree’s ham-fisted attempt to strong-arm the Senate into passing his unconstitutional lawful access bill as-is.
New episodes released early for C$7+ subscribers. This week, @supriya.bsky.social and I discuss the government's decision to dig in its heels on its very bad lawful access bill. #cdnpoli
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T00:22:15.927Z
Ukraine Dispatch:
A Russian missile and drone attack on Kyiv hit two bridges and other critical infrastructure. Ukraine has launched its largest drone attack on Russia yet, hitting oil refineries as well as the strategic bridge linking Russia to occupied Crimea.
Noteworthy:
- Richard Warnica absolutely savages Danielle Smith’s gerrymandering plans.
- Kevin Carmichael suggests that it’s not a bad thing that the federal budget has upset the small business lobby.
- Carmichael also reflects on Tiff Macklem’s time as Bank of Canada governor, as he announces he’ll be stepping down in June.
- Justin Ling calls for an end to the Poilievre era of conservatism in this country (but his rose-coloured view of the O’Toole years was a bit off).
- Althia Raj hears from Elizabeth May as she steps down as Green Party leader.
- Raj also calls for transparency with the Major Projects Office on their interchange personnel.
- Paul Wells travels to Latvia to see our troops stationed there, and gets a look at Canadian companies testing new technologies there.
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.
Not betting anything that there will be a byelection on Saanich—Gulf Islands for Mr. McMorice to get a seat ASAP?