QP: Scott Moe loves the budget!

The PM was still in China, while all of the other leaders were present. Pierre Poilievre led off in French, and he dog-whistled about people who can’t get healthcare while the government keeps bringing in more immigrants. Lina Diab responded by boasting that there are 5000 spaces reserved for more healthcare workers and further investments in the budget. Poilievre switched to English to repeat the same dog-whistle about immigrants taking healthcare, and Diab repeated her same assurances about spaces. Poilievre mocked that this wouldn’t need the overall levels and that there are doctors and nurses who can’t get licensed, and claimed they have a “Blue Seal” plan to solve that. (They actually don’t because that’s entirely the domain of the provinces). Patty Hajdu reminded him that this is a provincial responsibility and that their attempts to work with them to resolve that get voted down by Conservatives. Poilievre then lambasted “foreign spending” when people can’t afford to eat at home (which doesn’t make any sense). François-Philippe Champagne got up to praise the budget and to exhort the Conservatives to vote for the implementation bill. Poilievre kept mocking the same rainforest fund and claimed Brookfield was cutting it down, and this time Tim Hodgson got up to exhort Poilievre to support the forestry industry in the budget. Poilievre kept up to mock the “gender-just rice” spending, while Hodgson listed projects the Conservatives have an opportunity to support.

Yves-François Blanchet led for the Bloc, and he worried about the prime minister’s potential conflicts of interest. Steve MacKinnon reminded him that there is a robust ethics system that everyone follows. Blanchet continued to insist that there was adequate transparency on Carney’s assets and shares, and MacKinnon repeated his same assurances. Blanchet tried a third time and got the same response. 

Round two, and Michael Chong raised the PBO’s concerns about the pace of housing starts (Champagne: Scott Moe called this the best budget in a decade), and worried about cuts to Commissionaires and cadet activities (Champagne: The Canadian Chamber of Commerce loves the budget), Sandra Cobena accused the government of cooking the books around the operating budget (Long: Your leader’s staff is fleeing to BC; Your caucus is divided), Vincent Neil Ho also quoted the PBO on the deficit and housing (Robertson: We are focused on housing supply, and here are some quotes), and Eric Lefebvre read the same script in French (Ménard: Why are you calling supports for people “useless spending”?; this is about keeping jobs and increasing productivity).

Patrick Bonin complained that the government forced a vote against a “common sense” amendment to Bill C-39 (Dabrusin: The bill doesn’t reduce standards; Conserving nature is a priority).

Grant Jackson picked up the dog-whistle to equate healthcare wait times with higher immigration (Hajdu: You are obstructing on help for youth unemployment), Michelle Rempel Garner took her turn on the dog-whistle (Diab: You know this is not true—and got warned by the Speaker—before pointing out the majority of new permanent residents are already here; Those are fabricate numbers), and Gérard Deltell blew the dog-whistle en français (Diab: The steep decline in arrivals have relieved some of the pressure), and worried about any conflicts the PM has with Telesat (MacKinnon: He’s undertaken to a conflict screen).

The Conservatives have turned the dog-whistle about immigration stealing healthcare into a gods damned foghorn. This is gross. #QP

— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-18T19:46:04.318Z

Round three saw questions on Stellantis/Roshel (Joly: The number one priority is to protect jobs, like we did for Stelco; The only company we were negotiating with is Stellantis), Telesat’s contract (MacKinnon: I don’t know what you are alleging but there are clear rules we follow; We’d all like to know who you are a mouthpiece for; All disclosures have been made proactively), layoffs at a mill after getting government funds (Hodgson: We understand how challenging the tariffs are for the industry which is why we have supports and a strategy in the budget), the PrescribeIT audit (Michel: We will share the results once we have them), rainforest funds to a “communist” in Brazil (Dabrusin: We care deeply about affordability, but the money is a loan to a fund co-managed by Norway that will protect forests), and Carney’s comments about oligopolies competing re: telecom (Joly: We will due our due diligence on this proposal).

How, pray tell, would the federal government have stopped the Stellantis sale when it’s a domestic sale to a domestic company? This is such terrible theatre on both sides. 🎭 #QP

— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-18T19:53:56.475Z

Matt Strauss thinks he’s going to get a Tony for his ridiculous performance. Rest assured, he won’t.FFS #QP

— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-18T20:05:30.314Z

Overall, we find ourselves at that most terrible time of year where the government largely responds to all questions by reciting quotes praising their recent budget, which just cheapens the whole exercise. The Conservatives are using a racist foghorn around immigration, and the government refuses to push back or call any of it out, which is extremely bad for the country as a whole. And amidst all of the terrible, cheap theatre over either immigration, the deficit, or the Stelco issue, we got an actual decent question from Todd Doherty about the mill in his riding that took government money and then announced layoffs, which the government should have actually answered honestly, or at the very least, taken under advisement to look into what happened, but what did we get instead? Bluster from Tim Hodgson about the fact that there’s a forestry strategy in the budget. That wasn’t the question, and you had an opportunity to look like you take your job seriously rather than just a talking point delivery mechanism. It’s just so ridiculous all around.

Sartorially speaking, snaps go out to Dominique Vien for a long silver jacket with a black square pattern, over a black turtleneck and slacks, and to Ben Carr for a dark blue suit with a pink shirt and a navy tie. Style citations go out to Eric Lefebvre for a khaki-coloured suit with a navy shirt and a tan tartan tie, and to Sophie Chatel for a high-necked zip-up jacket with a collection of differently patterned blocks that were haphazardly assembled, along with black slacks. 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.