This government’s rhetoric on lawful access continues to make me absolutely apoplectic, particularly because they are buying into horseshit police narratives that they’re just poor widdle babies who can’t possibly fight crime online if they have to do things like their due diligence in getting judicial warrants, so instead, they need the government to create a surveillance state for their benefit. And that’s exactly what’s happening, and as you might expect, they have the police lining up to give lurid horror stories to legacy media about how our lack of lawful access powers means that we’re some kind of haven for child exploitation online. It’s not true, and they can do the work to get warrants if it’s urgent—telewarrants exist! I have quite spoken to former judges who used to sign off on wiretap authorisations for terror suspects, who told me that it’s no problem if the police have their evidence in order, which is the real trick here. That’s the due diligence they don’t want to do. Easier to create mass state-enabled surveillance and say that if you don’t let them, you’re just helping the child exploiters. Remember how that worked for Vic Toews in Stephen Harper’s government? This is very bad, guys. We should’t sleepwalk on this.
Meanwhile, the Carney stans obstinately refuse to understand that he's doing things that even Stephen Harper backed down from doing.
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-19T02:57:10.428Z
Housing
There has been a lot of attempts over the past couple of days to try and find some kind of gotcha with the government after the PBO’s report on housing starts, and recent CMHC data, and trying to get Gregor Robertson to reaffirm the plans to double housing starts, which he wouldn’t do. Instead, he made the remark that they can’t force people to build more houses, but they’re doing what they can with non-market housing. And that’s fair! But once again, the provinces are absent from this conversation when it’s their gods damned responsibility. There are so many things that provinces need to do, whether it’s legalising European-style single-stair apartment buildings, changing elevator regulations to meet cheaper and easier to maintain European standards, broad-based rezoning using provincial authorities, or giving municipalities different funding tools for infrastructure so that they don’t rely on development fees that make housing prohibitively expensive to build. And provinces are pretty much doing none of those things, while they simply demand more money from the federal government. We’re so utterly boned because nobody holds the provinces to account.
My Latest:
My column lays into Danielle Smith’s plans to gerrymander her next election.
Ukraine Dispatch:
Three waves of Russian attacks on Odesa have killed four people. Ukraine’s drone attacks over the past few weeks have reduced Russian refining capacity by 45 percent. Here is a look at Operation Vivaldi, which countered Russian advances and push back along the eastern front. Canada has announced another tranche of aid for Ukraine in the form of ammunition, military meal packs, and winter clothing and gear.
Noteworthy:
- Conservatives are privately grousing that a loss in Brantford—Brandt will likely be a turning point in Poilievre’s leadership, but he is likely to be motivated to leave.
- Michael Kovrig adds some good context about China’s role in the Nvidia scandal.
The front of Centre Block is fully wrapped in the trompe d’oeil, while the Peace Tower is slowly being enveloped by scaffolding.
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-18T20:56:45.079Z
Want more Routine Proceedings? Become a patron and get exclusive new content.