The PM was still in China, while Pierre Poilievre was present, and he led off in French, and he wailed about immigration levels and how this was going to be terrible for people finding housing or doctors. Joël Lightbound stood up to take issue with the dismissal of housing figures, and praised the government was doing. Poilievre switched to English to ask the same thing, characterised as “mass Liberal immigration,” and Gregor Robertson patted himself on the back for the “unprecedented” housing investments in the budget. Poilievre said the only ones who benefit from this immigration are “corporate power brokers,” and Robertson again disputed the housing numbers. Poilievre tried again, with a pathetic populist flourish, and François-Philippe Champagne got up to proclaim the “generational” investment in housing in the budget. Poilievre mocked the response as the Liberals “failing expensively,” and Champagne insisted that Canadians understand the difference between expenses and capital investment. (Do they? Do they really?) Poilievre then shot back that it’s the finance minister who doesn’t know the difference, and returned to French to lament spending levels while growth is depressed. Champagne insisted that Canadians understand that there is a generational budget to build the country.
Poilievre is dog-whistling about “mass Liberal immigration” as he concern trolls about housing levels, but then says this benefits “corporate power brokers.” #QP
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T19:21:38.290Z
Christine Normandin led for the Bloc, and she denounced Bill C-39, quoting a number of witnesses and lamented that all substantive amendments were voted down. Steven MacKinnon recited the good-news talking points about how great this was for everyone in the country. Normandin quoted the Liberal backbenchers and the Liberal Women’s Commission who are against the bill, and Julie Dabrusin insisted that they are listening to Canadians, and they want us to build a stronger future, and claimed that environmental standards remain in place. (Erm…) Patrick Bonin took over to make the same points again, and MacKinnon mocked the Bloc for not supporting high speed rail.
Round two, and Michelle Rempel Garner who recounted the woes of someone who can’t get a job and blamed immigration (Fragiskatos: You keep quoting projected levels while most of the those getting permanent residency are already here; This is a one-time measures for Ukrainians and Hong Kongers which your MPs were calling for), Brad Redekopp blamed a hospital death on immigration (Hajdu: Don’t demonise immigration and Build Canada Strong™), Pierre Paul-Hus also complained about immigration (Lightbound: Quebec already has control over economic migrant levels and this is a one-time measure), and Melissa Lantsman quoted the PBO’s remarks on the budget and demanded the “real numbers” (Long: Your leader is losing staff faster than he built houses as housing minister—which, again, is not what happened; Let’s look at the economic fundamentals).
Brad Redekopp blamed an ER death on immigration and not THE FUCKING PREMIER WHO UNDERFUNDED THE SYSTEM! #QP
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T19:33:32.962Z
Rhéal Fortin wailed about how much the government spent defending the Charter against Quebec’s legislation (Fraser: There are no circumstance where the Supreme Court of Canada considers a constitutional interpretation without the participation of the government of Canada; Lightbound: Read the brief tabled by the Attorney General).
The very masculine Jacob Mantle railed about the trade deal with China (Naqvi: Hooray for the PM expanding the trade agreement!; Here is a quote from Scott Moe in favour of this), Stephanie Kusie read the same again (MacDonald: You are talking down our farmers who are getting a good deal; The industry stakeholders are very grateful for everything we are doing), while Luc Berthold read the same script en français (Leitão: We are negotiating an agreement and 50,000 imported EVs won’t shake the industry).
Round three saw questions on Stellantis/Roshel (Leitão: We have been talking with Stellantis for over a year, and we will work with those who who work with us; We have been clear since the start that we want the jobs back and if not, we will get the money back; Bardeesy: We have been clear that Stellantis has commitments; We are defending the Canadian auto sector against tariffs which we don’t hear from you guys), tariffs hurting a local business vs contributing to a rainforest fund (LeBlanc: We are concerned about these businesses and are working with provinces to support them), that rainforest fund versus forestry (Dabrusin: This is important globally), the business case for high-speed rail (MacKinnon: We will build this transformation project that will be the spine of travel in this country; We will deal with affected farmers in an equitable way; that report says that alternatives would be just about as expensive without the benefits of high-speed), Quebecor’s proposed takeover of Telus (Leitão: There is no deal on the table, but if there is a serious proposal, then there is an independent regulatory process), and past pledges to eliminate homelessness (Robertson: We are focused in this budget on solutions).
THAT’S NOT WHAT “GASLIGHTING” MEANS!FFS. #QP
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T19:52:58.350Z
“Gender-just rice!” So hilarious/outrageous! #QP
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T20:01:24.719Z
Overall, it was one of those QPs that got increasingly frustrating the longer it went on, in part because of the level of absolute bullshit being thrown around. Today’s frame for the mainline questions was the PBO’s latest report, which was “proof” that the government wasn’t building enough housing, ergo immigration bad. No, seriously. And the line that the only ones who benefit from higher immigration are “corporate power brokers” is a line that doesn’t make sense, but one suspects is intended to be a vibe-based populist pitch that doesn’t logically make any sense and is once again making the Conservatives trying to sound like they’re Dollarama NDP instead of their usual ideological position of being corporate apologists. That, of course, doesn’t excuse the dog-whistling about immigration, because it’s not exactly subtle.
The other baffling refrain that the Conservatives kept coming to was the rainforest fund contribution, which the government mostly just ignored, though Julie Dabrusin defended it at one point. The logic of the Conservative position is that somehow, this “foreign spending” somehow either punishes Canadians who are suffering, or that it contributes to the deficit which magically fuels inflation (it does not), and that inflation then magically raises food and housing prices (which is not how inflation works). And then we got in the “gender-just rice” as an additional punchline/ragebait point thrown in as well, which is the dumbest punching bag in the Conservative arsenal. It’s all so very stupid, but nobody on the government side will actually call this out, and instead are patting themselves on the back for the budget instead. I understand that this is all about getting clips, but it doesn’t make it any less frustrating to watch.
Sartorially speaking, snaps go out to Melissa Lantsman for a navy jacket over a white collared shirt and black slacks, and to Pierre Paul-Hus for a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt and a light purple tie. Style citations go out to Burton Bailey for a grey windowpane patterned jacket over a white shirt, dark grey slacks, and a deep purple tie, and to Dominique O’Rourke for a black long-sleeved top with pale red and pink florals over black slacks.