The PM was somewhere over the Pacific, while Pierre Poilievre was in Quebec to highlight his by-elections candidates for the press. That left Jasraj Hallan to lead off with his usual vaguely insulting rushed word salad about the deficit and a swipe at Gregor Robertson, who got up to assure him that they are totally focused on housing affordability, and that rents have been down for 25 consecutive months. Hallan was mid-swipe when the Speaker warned him about his references to other honourable members. Hallan went on about “banker buddies,” to which Robertson reminded him that when he was mayor in Vancouver, the Conservative prime minister didn’t lift a finger to help him end homelessness. Sandra Cobena took over to complain that the government spent through their oil price windfall, to which François-Philippe Champagne insisted that the deficit is down and they are balancing the operating budget early. Cobena called this a shell game, and demanded a “credible plan” to balance the budget. Champagne responded with a quote from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce. Luc Berthold then took over and he repeated the same concerns about the deficit en français. Champagne responded with Quebec-based quotes in praise of the budget, and invited the Conservatives to support it. Berthold claimed the budget would put Canada “up against the wall” with the debt, before he pivoted to concerns about steel imports from China. Champagne insisted that they have always supported the Canadian industry, and demanded support for the budget.
Yves-François Blanchet led for the Bloc, and described the Bloc’s bill to prevent climate backsliding and demanded the government support it. Julie Dabrusin insisted that Canada was a leader, particularly around methane emissions and the COP conference recognised that. Blanchet tried to get support for the bill a second time, and this time Steven MacKinnon got up to ask if they could count on Bloc support to reduce emissions with the high-speed rail project. Blanchet tried a third time for support, and MacKinnon cited a study about electrification and how good it will be for Quebec’s economy.
Round two, and Costas Menegakis railed that the government has “lost all control” of immigration and blamed all problems on this (Diab: I’m proud of our plan which keeps levels sustainable), Michelle Rempel Garner concern trolled about gender in immigration (Diab: The department does gender-based analysis and your province’s business council supports it; The budget has a lot of initiatives for young people), Frank Caputo recited some dubious statistics about crime (Anandasangaree: We are taking action at a pace never seen before; Why are you slow-walking lawful access?); Connie Cody worried cooper thefts (Sahota: We included copper theft in Bill C-14), and Kelly DeRidder worried about money laundering (Sahota: We are creating a financial crimes agency).
Xavier Barsalou-Duval worried about the “authoritarian” turn of Bill C-39 (MacKinnon: This bill is about creating an investment environment; Quebeckers in my riding want more economic opportunities).
John Barlow gave some nonsense about government spending driving up costs for farmers (MacDonald: We are doing agricultural research), Dave Epp complained that the “Mega-Deduction” doesn’t include agricultural (MacDonald: It does include incentives for farmers, so you should read the budgets), Jacques Gourde insisted the government direct some of its spending to farmers (MacDonald: The budget has provisions for farmers, unlike your election platform; MacKinnon: I also love agriculture, and hooray for high-speed rail).
Government spending does not drive up farmer’s costs. For. Fuck. Sakes. #QP
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-19T19:42:22.117Z
Round three saw questions on Huawei and ZTE not actually being banned (Joly: We tie nation to security seriously), Stellantis/Roshel (Joly: A Chinese automaker was never part of the deal; You never bring up the American tariffs; You said the same thing about Stelco and now the workers are coming back; Solomon: We are supporting workers), the Telesat contract (MacKinnon: There is no conflict; Hooray for the work of the industry minister), rainforest funds versus spending cuts at home (Hodgson: You are against protecting forests around the world while we have a forestry strategy; Sarai: Canada’s loan will help protect a billion hectare over 70 countries; We thought conservation was something Conservatives could get behind; Romanado: I know the cadet programme very well, and we have allocated more funds to them), deficits (Long: We are coming from a position of strength), the comments from past environment ministers on our climate record (Dabrusin: We support our Paris targets and the budget has the investments we need for electrification), and privatisation (Joly: Affordability is our top priority).
John Brassard, puffing out his chest, accuses the government of puffing out their chests. This is so stupid. #QP
— Dale Smith (@journodale.bsky.social) 2026-11-19T19:54:56.822Z
Overall, it was a more scattershot day where a lot of different MPs were fishing for clips, both on the usual topics of the past week around the budget, but also a number of other items whether it’s tough-on-crime grousing or agriculture supports. (One of my media colleagues noted that Dave Epp is not one usually given to hyperbole, so he is curious about the matter and whether Epp or the minister is wrong). The accusations around the Stellantis plant sale keep getting more ridiculous with every passing day, and when the minister doesn’t explicitly deny whatever is said, the Conservatives keep using that as some kind of “proof” that their wild accusations have some merit. I get that the government keeps trying to frame everything in the positive, but come on guys. You can do better when it comes to countering this absolute bullshit, and the more you don’t, the more it just festers in the public’s imagination.
Sartorially speaking, snaps go out to John-Paul Danko for a dark grey three-piece suit with a white shirt and a grey and blue paisley tie and matching pocket square, and to Michelle Rempel Garner for a black leather jacket over a black top and slacks. Style citations go out to Anita Vandenbeld for a black and gold top under a burgundy jacket, and to Alex Ruff for a navy jacket, moss green slacks, a light blue shirt and a blue and grey checkerboard tie.